The Occupation Has Many Faces—Take the Olive Harvest, for Example
Doron Meinret, Looking the Occupation in the Eye
"The IDF Spokesperson stated that following an advance field reconnaissance and a professional assessment of operational conditions – conducted with the intention of securing the tour – it was determined that security could not be provided. The decision was made solely on the basis of security considerations, without any extraneous motives. Following the denial of security and the refusal to grant entry into a closed military zone, the tour organizers decided not to hold it." (Amos Harel, Haaretz)
One of the greatest disasters to befall us is that military officers at every rank have turned lying into a habit. One of the most important things a new government will need to do is clean out the stables – including the IDF’s stables, and specifically the stalls belonging to the IDF Spokesperson and the Head of the Central Command.
Here is the context: Former PM Ehud Olmert wanted to come harvest olives in the West Bank to demonstrate his opposition to the outrageous, criminal violence of the settlers and security forces against Palestinians in general, and against their ability to harvest their olives in particular. The harvest planned for that day had been fully coordinated and arranged in advance, including a preliminary site visit, submitting participants' details, and completing every required procedure. The night before, Central Command notified Maj. Gen. (Res.) Yaakov Or (Mandy) and the Shin Bet’s VIP Protection Unit that the area had been declared a "closed military zone" and that the harvest could not take place. It wasn’t "the organizers decided" – it was the Head of Central Command who decided, undoubtedly under dual pressure: from the settler-terrorist lords of the land on one side, and from the occupant of the Defense Minister’s office on the other.
Those who are managing to get out there, harvest olives, and act on behalf of Palestinians are the group of former senior defense officials led by Maj. Gen. (Res.) Eyal Ben-Reuven ("Ad Hoc"), as detailed in Noa Limona’s thorough and excellent article in the Haaretz Weekend Magazine on November 5. The article recounts an incident that took place in Duma a few weeks ago, and since then the group has continued going out every week. This week I joined them between Qusra and Jalud, and we succeeded in harvesting olives just a few hundred meters from Tubasi’s home in Jalud – the very house where the military failed to enforce a High Court directive to return the residents, and where soldiers were beaten by settlers when they tried to carry it out. Just a week earlier, the landowners had tried to reach the plot we worked on and were driven away by the army. Going in with us was the first time they had managed to reach it in a year – much like a month ago, when the group’s presence enabled us to bring water to another community that settlers, backed by the military, have deprived of water supplies for months.
Eyal, Mandy, and the former officials working with them operate in full partnership with us – Looking the Occupation in the Eye – and with other grassroots organizations. We are the ones who connect them with Palestinians, share what is truly happening on the ground, and refute the lies of the officers and the IDF Spokesperson. We link them up with Palestinians who need assistance, guide them to the places where they are needed, and stand alongside them throughout the activity.
This week I met with another former senior official – a high-ranking officer who was part of the leadership behind the protests against the judicial coup. He told me he completely agrees with my analysis: that the occupation is the root cause of most of our problems, including the judicial coup. Yet at the time, he opposed raising the issue at the demonstrations and opposed the presence of the Anti-Occupation Bloc at those protests, hoping that religious Israelis and liberal right-wingers would show up. In hindsight, he realizes that was a mistake (Radman said similar things recently).
And even now, some members within the coalition of organizations trying to promote a joint Jewish-Arab government suggest that we should "be smart rather than right" and explain that "now is not the time."
After the strategists – so "smart" yet not right – who proposed sugarcoating reality in order to win voters over from right to left have failed; and after virtually no "moderate right-winger" and no "liberal religious" voter left the bloc of destruction to vote for the bloc of change, I propose Doron’s Three-Step Method for Engaging with Reality:
- Look reality straight in the eye.
- Describe publicly, in writing and in speech, what you see.
- Act openly and with all your strength to change reality.
I am considering offering a ten-session course, at a special promotional price, to teach this method.





