I Will Not Be Silent as My Country Changes
Rabbi Lana Zilberman Soloway, Co-Chair of Rabbis for Human Rights
I love this land. It is my home, and the place where I choose to raise my children. It is precisely because of this love that I cannot remain silent in the face of injustice committed here. I am committed to take responsibility for what happens here in my name.
On Wednesday, October 21, 2026, as a spiritual leader, activist, and Co-Chair of Rabbis for Human Rights, I joined the organization’s annual olive harvest, alongside eighty Israeli and international activists. I went as a woman, an Israeli, a rabbi, and a human rights activist, believing that love of this land obligates me to stand alongside the people who live here. I had no idea that the day would end with my arrest and an order barring me from the West Bank for thirty days.
We arrived in the Palestinian village of Nahalin to help families who had been unable to reach their olive groves since October 7, 2023. We came to help farmers harvest their crops and stand in solidarity with them.
The morning began peacefully and quietly. In the grove, we met elderly Palestinian women, the owners of the land, who welcomed us with joy and excitement. We harvested olives and worked together.
For a moment, all that mattered was the shared act itself: people reaching out to help one another.
About two hours later, large forces of the military and police arrived. They informed us that the area had been declared a closed military zone and ordered us to leave. We asked to pack up peacefully, return to our vehicles, and go home. Instead, we were separated - Israelis on one side, international activists on the other - and transported in separate vehicles to the police station in Beitar Illit.
The international activists, including rabbis and a member of Congress, underwent security checks and were taken into the station. We Israelis waited in our vehicles for hours. Among us was an eighty-year-old Palestinian woman, the owner of the land where we had been working. It was impossible not to think about the absurdity of the situation: women seeking to reach their own olive grove, and volunteers who had come to help them, had suddenly become a threat to state security.
After nearly nine hours in detention, under degrading conditions and without food or water, we were released subject to conditions that included a thirty-day ban on entering the West Bank, a financial guarantee, and additional warnings. The international activists were ostensibly released without conditions, but when they returned to their homes abroad, they received an email informing them that their Israeli entry visas had been canceled.
I returned home carrying an order barring me from the West Bank. It hurts not only because it restricts my freedom of movement, but because it prevents me from standing alongside the people and families I have committed to not abandon.
My arrest is not the heart of this story.
The heart of the story is the reality in which Palestinian families live under occupation and military rule, struggling every day to access their land and earn a living. During the olive harvest, this reality becomes especially stark. Violence by radical settler youth, property damage, and restrictions on access to olive groves undermine farmers’ ability to reach their land and gather their crops.
I want to make an important distinction: not all settlers engage in violence, and it is unjust to assign collective responsibility to an entire community. Some settlers oppose violence and actively work to protect Palestinian rights. Responsibility lies with those who choose to attack and threaten others, and with the authorities, whose duty is to protect those at risk and ensure that they can exercise their rights.
The following day, my friends and fellow activists went out to harvest olives again, in open areas accessible to everyone. I could not join them, but knowing that they were continuing their work in the spirit of peace, compassion, justice, and solidarity strengthened me.
As a spiritual leader, someone who teaches Torah and seeks to live by its teachings, I find it difficult to accept any attempt to separate love of the land from moral responsibility toward every human being who lives here.
In Leviticus 19:34 it is written:
“The stranger who resides with you shall be to you as one of your citizens; you shall love them as yourself, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt.”
The Torah reminds us of our experience as strangers in Egypt not merely so that we will remember our past, but so that we will act differently in the present. Jewish memory is not only a story of what was done to us. It is a commitment to recognize injustice when it is inflicted on others and to work to repair it, even when doing so comes at a personal cost.
I will not be silent as my country changes beyond recognition. I refuse to grow accustomed to a reality in which farmers cannot reach their own land, violence threatens families, and extending a helping hand to those in need becomes grounds for arrest.
I call on all of us to do more than condemn violence. We must act to stop it: demand that the authorities protect Palestinian farmers, guarantee their access to their land, investigate attacks, and bring those responsible to justice. We must show up on the ground, stand alongside those whose rights are being denied, and speak out clearly against every attempt to normalize injustice.
I cannot change this reality alone, but I can choose not to accept it. Love of this land obligates us to work hard for the kind of society we want it to be - to build a place where every person’s rights are upheld, regardless of national identity.
May we learn to transform Jewish memory into moral responsibility, and our prayers for peace into actions that bring peace closer. This land cannot truly be a home worthy of the name as long as one people’s freedom and dignity depend on denying the rights of another.
The responsibility to change this reality belongs to all of us.






